| Supertramp
- 5
Surely/ It's A Long Road/ Aubade-And
I Am Not Like Other Birds of Prey/ Words Unspoken/ Maybe I'm A
Begger/ Home Again/ Nothing to Show/ Shadow Song/ Try Again/
Surely
When reviewing albums of a
particular band/artist I always like to start at the beginning and
work forwards in time in an attempt to see how progression came
about. This is often a difficult process and Supertramp are a good
example of just why. Much of their later material is very well
known and so trying to forget what is to come is quite difficult.
There is certainly something about this album, although in the
main it is probably forgettable as the songwriting skills of Roger
Hodgson and Rick Davis are by no means fully formed. In fact it
just doesn't sound like a Supertramp album. I have a sneaking
regard for "Words Unspoken" but in the main it's almost
as if this is an experimental album with plenty of extraneous
waffle included as shown in the last three minutes of "Maybe
I'm a Begger". Weighing in at over 12 minutes "Try
Again" is the first of the bands magnum opus' This is a
strange piece of music, opening with a medieval style meandering
which gives way to some almost throaty vocals. Unlike Fools'
Overture which was to come later, this lengthy piece is not really
together - too many almost experimental passages sewn together to
give it almost a jamming sound where those taking part probably
enjoyed it more than those of us listening. And in many ways that
sums up the whole feel of the album.
|
 |
| Indelibly
Stamped - 4.5
Your Poppa Don't Mind/ Travelled/
Rosie Had Everything Planned/ Remember/ Forever/ Potter/ Coming
Home to See You/ Times Have Changed/ Friend in Need/ Aries
Let's get the obvious out of the
way to start with. The cover has to be one of the worst in rock
music history. It's of Rusty Skuse whose husband was (surprise
surprise) a tattooists. It's point alludes me but it does
immediately detract from the album. The first album "Supertramp"
was commercially something of a failure and this one trod the same
path. It's reasonably easy to see why. There are a few lighter
feel numbers here that are quite fun but overall its rather a
bland mix of folk and jazz influences overlaying some very average
material and still not really hinting at the fully fledged band
that would emerge in the shape of the glorious Crime of the
Century.
|
 |
| Crime
of the Century - 8
School/ Bloody Well Right/ Hide in
Your Shell/ Asylum/ Dreamer/ Rudy/ If Everyone Was Listening/
Crime of the Century
The essence of a classic rock/pop
album is atmosphere. The whole needs certainly to be more than a
sum of the parts. The album has to have a wow factor. Often you
cannot describe in words just what that wow factor is. Certainly
this is the case with Crime of the Century which is a million
miles away in feel to the first two albums. Here we have genuinely
good songs that merge together to produce a stunningly good album
of the mid seventies. Somehow they seem to steal from the times.
It was no fluke that many of these songs became part of a staple
Supertramp set. You could be forgiven for believing that this was
the band's debut album and not their third brought out four years
and a few financial worries after their first. It is a richly
rounded offering. From the opening wails that start School you
know that something special is brewing. No pointless
experimentation here - it all feeds in effortlessly to produce
some powerful songs with the indelible Supertramp style. School
hammers along at some pace, Bloody Well Right is perhaps a little
too overblown whereas Hide in Your Shell is my favourite all
time Supertramp songs - a wonderful marrying of music and lyrics.
Dreamer is quite rightly one of the band's most popular pieces and
the title track
|
 |
| Crisis?
What Crisis - 6.5
Easy Does It/ Sister Moonshine/
Aint Nobody But Me/ A Soapbox Opera/ Another Woman's Woman/ Lady/
Poor Boy/ Just a Normal Day/ The Meaning/ Two of Us
It was always going to be difficult
to follow something as good a Crime of the Century, but Crisis?
What Crisis was a pretty good effort with some decent, if not
classic, material on it. There's a nice Eastern feel about the
opening track and there is a distinctive warmth throughout the
album. although at times the material might fall just short of the
mark. There is more of a simple feel to this album. Whether that
is a good thing or not is open to personal opinion. At times the
music does become more middle-of-the-road but at least there is
some kind of progression and in "Two of Us" the band put
together one of their more enduring songs. Throughout the album
there's plenty to interest the discerning listener.
|
 |
| Even
In The Quietest Moments - 6
Give a Little Bit/ Lover Boy/ Even
in the Quietest Moments/ Downstream/ Babaji/ From Now On/ Fools
Overture
Take one of the band's greatest
prog achievements in the 11 minute Fools Overture and surround it
with pretty forgettable songs and you pretty much have Even in the
Quietest Moments. The Overture so overshadows everything else on
the album that it makes it very difficult to assess. It is a
tremendous swirling piece with jazz and classical influences, Nazi
war chants, Churchilian speeches, the striking of Big Ben. William
Blakes' words to Jerusalem and snatches from Holst's Planets also
find their way into this piece of classic Roger Hodgson writing
and made the album a worthwhile purchase on its own. Sadly the
remainder is rather thin. Give a Little Bit is one of those
annoying songs that you end up singing along with but not liking
much. From Now On is quite an impressive piece in many ways but
ends in an annoying sing-a-long feel. Did you know that for the
cover photograph the band actually took a piano up a mountain in
Colorado. Seems a little far to go for an album that is rather
sparse in highlights.
|
 |
| Breakfast
in America - 7.5
Gone Hollywood/ The Logical Song/
Goodbye Stranger/ Breakfast in America/ Oh Darling/ Take the Long
Way Home/ Lord Is It Mine/ Just Another nervous Wreck/ Casual
Conversations/ Child of Vision
Oh for the glorious musical
differences. Roger Hodgson and Rick Davies began to fall out (as
members of rock bands are wont to do), Apparently Davies didn't
like the title song or the name of the album. Thankfully both
stayed and Supertramp managed to have four hit singles from this
album - The Logical Song, Goodbye Stranger, Breakfast in America
and Take the Long Way Home. Most of the material on this album is
so well known that it's difficult to comment on the album as a
whole. It was certainly more powerful than Even in the Quietest
Moments and had a fully fledged Americana feel to it. It became a
huge success on both sides of the Atlantic - proving that there is
a midway point between American and British musical tastes.
"Gone Hollywood" is a difficult song to pin down - at
times raucous, at times melodic and the kind of music Scissor
Sisters have used to such good effect. Then come the trio of hits.
"The Logical Song" is wonderfully original and in the
tradition of much of the band's previous output, Goodbye Stranger
is a genuine rocker (something that is often overlooked) and
Breakfast in America vindicates Hodgson's faith in the track. The
album would have been much weaker without it. It has a wonderfully
naive lyrics that is so effective. Less effective is Oh Darling
but this gives way to my favourite track on the album "Take
the Long Way Home" Possibly the remainder of the material
isn't as strong but there are good moments on Lord Is It Mine,
Casual Conversation is a harsh lyric wrapped in a pretty song and
the final track Child of Vision is rather rambling, over long and
self indulgent.
|
 |
| Famous
Last Words - 5.5
Crazy/ Put On Your Old Brown Shoes/
It's Raining Again/ Bonnie/ Know Who You Are/ My Kind of Lady.
C'est Le Bon/ Waiting So Long/ Don't Leave Me Now
By now the relationship between
Hodgson and Davies was becoming very strained and this would be
the last Supertramp album to feature Hodgson. It was always going
to be difficult to follow Breakfast in America, but here the band
have overthrown any pretensions towards prog rock and tried to
become a real pop band. Sadly this at times seriously detracts
from the feel of the album and saw them follow up the classic
Supertramp sound of "Breakfast" with a series of
strictly average songs. "It's Raining Again" provided
them with another hit single and I have always liked the bouncy
sound of C'est Le Bon. Sadly Famous Last Words is an apt title for
a band that seemed at this point to be in decline with little new
to offer and it is difficult to see where the unique sound of
"Breakfast in America" had gone to them. I wouldn't
quite say that they were going through the motions at this point,
but some fresh injection was certainly needed.
|
 |
| Brother
Where You Bound?
Cannonball/ Still in Love/ No In
Between/ Better Days/ Brother Where You Bound/ Ever Open Door
|
 |
| Free
as a Bird
It's Alright/ Not the Moment/ It
Doesn't Matter/ Where I Stand/ Free As A Bird/ I'm Beggin You/ You
Never Can Tell With Friends/ Thing For You, An Awful Thing to
Waste
|
 |
| Some
Things Never Change
It's a Hard World/ You Win, I Lose/
Get Your Act Together/ Live to Love You/ Some Things Never Change/
Listen to Me Please/ Sooner or Later/ Help Me Down That Road/ And
the Light/ Give Me a Chance/ C'est What/ Where There's a Will
|
 |
| Slow
Motion
Slow Motion/ Little By Little/
Broken Hearted/ Over You/ Tenth Avenue Breakdown/ A Sting in the
Tail/ Bee in Your Bonnet/ Goldrush/ Dead Man's Blues
|
 |